It has been a common mistake down through the centuries for both preachers and listeners to be overly concerned about the "quality" of a sermon - whether the preacher was "boring" or "eloquent". Sadly, many people went to "famous preachers" more to be delighted by an excellent lecture than to really learn anything. Likewise, preachers often focused on giving a fine speech rather than guiding souls - missing the whole point of a sermon.

This condition was common in France in the 19th century. Among others, a particular high-ranking officer would go to hear sermons from the most celebrated orators in France. After Mass, on leaving the church, all he would talk about was high praise for the preacher’s eloquence.

Meanwhile, in the remote village of Ars, St. John Vianney had gained such a reputation that people of all walks of life, including bishops, would come to hear what he had to say on spiritual things. His listeners were deeply moved by his words.

Naturally, the officer heard of him, and wanted to listen to this great preacher for himself. Fr. Vianney’s sermon was much simpler than the officer was used to. There weren’t grand words and complex concepts. The saint simply made his points in a way that could be understood by everyone down to the little children.

After Mass, the officer left the church in silence. His servant was surprised, since the officer usually had lots to say in praise of sermons. So he broached the question of how had the officer liked the sermon.

In a subdued tone, the officer replied:

"In the past I have always been pleased with the preacher. Today I am displeased with myself."

For the first time in a long while, the officer heard a sermon which made him look inside himself - and in doing so, he found some things which needed correction. Truly it was the best sermon he had ever heard, for it served the purpose of a sermon, however complex or simple - to bring its hearers closer to God.